Well, my personal verdict is that Eclipse was a lots better than New Moon. One reason. More Edward face time. Lots of it. Dark, sulky, moody, and lots of other adjectives. Loved it. Seeing it again as soon as I can.
Favorite moments...
All of the scenes in the Cullen's house. The party, the family meetings, Edward and Bella.
The scene where they met with the wolves and practiced fighting. It reminded me of the baseball scene in the first movie.
Any scene where all of the Cullens were dressed in black and standing in a line looking fierce. Yes, I said fierce.
What was your favorite scene?
